button to main menu  Old Cumbria Gazetteer
Settle and Carlisle: accident 19101224
site name:-   Settle and Carlisle Railway
county:-   North Yorkshire
locality type:-   railway accident site
coordinates:-   SD77959373 (guess) 
1Km square:-   SD7793
10Km square:-   SD79

hearsay:-  
In 1910 instead of the Chief Mechanical Engineer, decisions about what sort of locomotives were used on the railway were made by the Traffic Department, their policy was frequent trains of light formation, using smaller locomotives. This policy necessitated the use of pilot engines on the steep gradients either side of Aisgill Summit. These were detached at Hawes Junction, now Garsdale Head, to return to their base. Consequently there were very many light engine movements on this part of the railway.
In the early hours of 24 December 1910 there were nine locomotives at Garsdale, waiting to return to their home stations. Two of them, class 2 2-4-0 engines nos.448 and 548, were forgotten by the over worked signalman. They set off towards Aisgill, obeying a signal for a following train at 5.43am. They had a slight start but were only travelling at about 30mph, followed by an express train to Scotland from London at 60-65mph which passed Garsdale at 5.47am.
When the day signlaman came on duty at 6.00am the error became apparent, but there was already a glow in the sky over Mallerstang. The night signalman said to the relief:-
"Will you go to Stationmaster Bunce and say that I am afraid I have wrecked the Scotch express."
The express was double headed, a Kirtley 2-4-0 no.48, and a 7ft class 2 rebuilt 4-4-0 no.549, which ran into the light engines in a violent collision. Both express engines and seven coaches were derailed, the first two carriages telescoped, and set on fire by escaping gas from the lighting equipment; all eight coaches were destroyed by fire. 12 persons died.
After this accident the Midland Railway improved safety measures at hundreds of sites, installing track circuiting. These are a corrective to signalmen's errors, but can't guard against a driver's failure to observe signals.

button to lakes menu  Lakes Guides menu.